We are taking the virus outbreak very seriously and have implemented additional sanitization, employee protocols, limited hours, and have closed the facility to any outside individuals. 

We have FULL STOCK of our product line and are shipping orders out Monday-Friday.  Orders are shipping in a 24-48 hour window.

Frequently Asked Questions

We are in the office Monday-Friday.  Each morning orders are batched and shipped, so orders typically go out the next day.  Keep in mind we don’t ship over the weekend, so orders that come in Friday will ship Monday.

Most orders ship USPS Priority nail and take 1-3 days depending on your proximity to us here in Upstate New York.  If you do not received your order within a week or ordering, feel free to give us a call and we can look into it for you.

We understand the urgency with your peanut butter order!

We’re sorry if you are not satisfied with your Saratoga Peanut Butter Company product.  If you are unhappy with a product, please contact us.  We will need the “BEST BY” date on the lid of your jar.

Someone from our customer service department will respond within 24 hours.  Please keep in mind, our offices are closed on the weekend.

Take pictures!!!  We are happy to assist you and understand what a disappointment it is when your order arrives damaged.  It is up there with the end of the world for the hard core PB lovers.

But seriously, we DO NEED PHOTOS to make a claim.  Photos of the label, damaged box, and box contents are required.  Once the photos are emailed to us, we can begin the claim and work on a solution to refund or replace.

We accept all major credit cards and PAYPAL.  If you must use a check or money order, please call the office to place your order.

There is NO SALES TAX on our food products.

We are currently working on shipping to Canada.  We can ship internationally and have for customers that really wanted the product and were open to the higher shipping charges.

All international orders must be placed by email or phone. Our website will not automatically process an international shipment.

Disclaimer: In the rare case that a manual package gets assessed, the recipient will be responsible for any duties and tax. It is difficult to determine the amount that will be due because it can vary from province to province.

We want to make sure you aware of duties and taxes and that occasionally a package may get assessed.

If a package does indeed get assessed, then the recipient will be notified by the carrier and will need to go to the local Post Office to pay and pick up the package if additional postage is due.

Our nut butters have a one-year shelf life from the manufacturing date and each lid is marked with a best by date.

We don’t recommend consuming the product after its best by date because there may be variances in consistency, taste and overall quality of the product.  Because natural nut butters do naturally separate, we feel the is tastes BEST if used in the first 6 months.   The store is responsible for removing soon-to-be expired (or already expired) products from the shelves.

If you purchased an expired product at a store, please return to the store where you purchased.  They should offer a full refund or at the very least, store credit.  Also, please feel free to let us know so we can contact the store!

Each Blend is a little different!  Our “creamiest” versions are the Plain Jane Creamy versions, Maple, and Blizzard.  Although, because of our small batch and homemade approach, there are tiny little bits/grit.  It will not be super smooth and globular like the processed peanut butters.

If you are a Chunky fan, Plain Jane Chunky and Chilin Chocolate are very chunky!

The rest of the blends have a creamy base, but have either added seeds/dried fruits which give it a consistency of its own!

We do not have any straight up sugar in the facility!   We do not add sugar directly to any products.  The only sugar in the products is from ingredients themselves , such as maple syrup, honey, chocolate, and/or dried fruits.

Saratoga Peanut Butter Company takes pride in not adding palm oils, refined sugars, or preservatives.  All products are low to no sodium, have no palm oils, and are low in sugar (if there is any at all).

Products we ship online and sell at our markets and festivals were just made, so oil separation is nonexistent or very minimal.  We ship FRESH Monday-Friday and have a very fast turn around time.  We have all products in stock online as well.

In the case that you purchased a jar from a retail store that is a bit more separated, do not fret!!!

Natural peanut butter doesn’t contain anything unnatural to interrupt the natural phenomenon of separation.  It is actually a good thing! It is the peanut oil from the peanuts themselves!  It is NOT added.

If you pour the oil out, your peanut butter won’t taste as good in the long run, and it’ll dry out much more quickly.  Don’t be afraid of a little peanut oil!

If your jar is noticeably separated, push a butter knife down through the nut butter paste into the oils. “Stab” through to the bottom and make holes to give the oil a chance to get back into the product.  Stab and stir!  It takes some elbow grease, but it works!

The nut butter will start to combine back into the oils and back to it’s original state.   

TIP : STORE YOUR JAR UPSIDE DOWN ON OCCASSION so that the oils are not always going up to the top of the jar, which can eventually leave you with a dry bottom. Just make sure the lid is on tight!

The choice if YOURS!    We always recommend giving your new jar a through stir with a study butter knife to start off with a well blended jar of product.

After that, feel free to store your jar at room temperature so that it is easier to spread or put it in the refrigerator if you think it will take you more than a couple of months to consume; this will keep your nut butter tasting fresh, longer and slow down the separation process if the jar is going to sit untouched for longer periods of time.  If you dig into your jar weekly, just always give it a quick stir and you shouldn’t have any issues.

Personally, the nuts over here at Saratoga PB leave ours at room temperature and go through the jar within a few months. Yum. (or days to be honest :/ )

TIP:  We hear that refrigerating our Blizzard makes it taste like cookie dough – minus all of the nasty sugars and junk!

All of our products are Gluten Free and NON GMO.   Many are vegan and all blends are dairy free except the ones that contain white chocolate (Blizzard and Seasonal Mistletoe)

All are soy free except our dark chocolate blends, Chilin Chocolate and Trifecta.   We do not add soy lecithin, but it is in the dark chocolate itself.

When looking into a product on the website, make sure to visit the product page which lists the ingredients so you can see the facts in more detail for your specific concerns.

Our products are manufactured on shared equipment.  We do take care to run almond butters on different days than peanut butters.  All equipment is cleaned and sanitized before running and when allergens are present.

We suggest making the decision for yourself if an allergy is present  and depending in the severity of your allergy.  You know best!!!

**** Allergen Statement:  Saratoga Peanut Butter Company products  are made in a facility that also processes PEANUTS, TREE NUTS (almonds), and SEEDS (flax seeds, pumpkin, and chia seeds).

A lot of our the steps taken to make Saratoga Peanut Butter Company’s products is by hand and in small batches.  For the most part, things are quite consistent.

Occasionally, our process can yield a slight inconsistency.  Each jar follows a strict recipe and has the same amount of each ingredient,  but can yield minor variations because of drier raisins, moisture levels in the nuts, or more moist blueberries for example.   You many find slight variation with the chunkiness and thickness from jar to jar. Please remember,  it’s a jar made with love every. single. time.

Are you seeing tiny white balls in the dark chocolate blends,  It is because there is cocoa butter in the chocolate . In the colder months when the natural oils start to separate, you may notice the cocoa butter solidify and turn white.

This is naturally occurring and is still perfectly good. Mix back in and the friction created allows it to melt right back into the butter!

All peanuts, nuts, and seeds, are roasted. One of the reasons we roast our nuts and seeds is to keep them free from pathogens.

All of our nuts and seeds are from the USA!!!   They are  Non-GMO, unpasteurized and roasted.  We source our nuts and seeds from various farmers in our country that demand a  high standard of quality.

Yes, the nuts come in from our suppliers with a Certificate of Analysis.  Our nuts are tested for E. Coli, , Aflatoxins, Salmonella, Listeria, Staph, Yeast, Mold, and Coliform.

YES!  We use a PET food safe plastic that is BPA-free and does not contain phthalates.  We use the plastic jars over glass because we had a lot of issues initially  with the weight of the glass and frequent breakage that occurred in the shipping process

We do not have any handling fees.  We offer an amazing $5 flat rate shipping charge on all orders over $20.00.  We take on the additional charge to save you and to make the products accessible to everyone.

Some stores are listed on the “Retailers” page on the site, but we do have many other accounts.  Feel free to email us or call, and we can give you the store(s) closet to you!  If you are a store and are interested, please contact us!

We occasionally run specials from time to time with seasonal blends, overstocked items and/or special times of the year, but for the most part our prices are firm.

We put a lot of effort into making a high quality and delicious product by using high quality ingredients and making sure our team is overseeing each step of the small batch process.  Our attention to detail and quality levels do cost more, so we hope you see the value added and feel our product is worth it!   We are going on 15 years strong and appreciate your support and patronage!

We also offer $5 flat rate shipping special on all orders over $30.00 ……and that is for as many jars as you want!

This is currently an ongoing promotion we offer so that customers who want more, but do not have a retail location nearby, can easily get there favorite PB

You can read about Jessica (women owned business)  in detail “Our Story” section!  We have been in business for 15 years.

We do not store your credit card numbers, only email addresses.

If you’d like to order Saratoga Peanut Butter products for your store, please visit our Wholesale page for more information.